Announcing his new deal with the EU today, Andy Burnham said the public were ahead of the politicians in wanting a closer relationship with Europe - and that the British people would be “the boss of what happens next”. He opened up the prospect of a conversation about our future relationship with Europe.
I think we should take him up on it.
For years, we’ve been expected to acknowledge the problems facing the country while being careful about mentioning Brexit’s contribution to them. Discuss weak growth, struggling businesses or young people’s prospects by all means. Suggest that our relationship with Europe might have something to do with any of it, and suddenly we are reopening old wounds.
Earlier this week, Burnham compared the reluctance to face up to Brexit’s failures to “the emperor’s new clothes”. He was right. There is something ridiculous about being asked to admire what Brexit was supposed to deliver while making excuses for what actually arrived. Less bureaucracy became more paperwork for businesses trading with Europe. New opportunities came with the loss of freedoms young people had previously enjoyed. The Office for Budget Responsibility still assumes that the trading arrangements will leave productivity 4% lower in the long run than if we had remained in the EU.
These are consequences people live with every day. They reach into the cost of the weekly shop, the costs of running a business, the jobs our economy can support and the opportunities open to young people. Burnham was right to bring the conversation back to those everyday concerns today.
We should be able to ask whether that is good enough.
Today’s deal gives us a reason to think about what better might look like. Removing barriers to food trade and restoring opportunities for young people are worthwhile things to do. Every unnecessary cost we can remove, every opportunity we can restore, improves somebody’s chances of making a success of their life.
For a young person, the chance to live, work or study somewhere else can change everything. A language learned, a career discovered, a relationship formed, a sense of what is possible that stays with them for the rest of their life. I struggle to see why protecting an old political argument should carry more weight than any of that.
The Government still has to deliver what it has promised. But each bit of damage we can undo gives us a reason to ask what else we could change.
That is why Burnham’s talk of “brainstorming” with European partners matters. It opens a door. We can look beyond the job of patching up the current arrangements and consider what would best serve the country in the years ahead. There will be costs, compromises and difficult choices. We are capable of discussing those too.
If you supported Brexit, you have just as much reason to be part of that conversation. You may have wanted more control over your life, better public services or politicians who paid some attention to your community. You are entitled to examine whether Brexit has delivered them, and whether the current arrangements are the best way to secure them now.
You may still conclude that they are. But that should be your judgement, reached with the evidence and alternatives in front of you.
The public cannot be the boss if the only acceptable answer is to carry on as we are.
For those of us at Open Britain, this is familiar territory. Many of you first came to know us through Brexit, and it has been a while since we addressed it this directly.
The years since have taken us deeper into the weaknesses in our democracy that the Brexit years exposed. How easily misleading claims could dominate a national debate. How much influence money could buy. Our vulnerability to foreign interference. How difficult it could be to hold politicians to account for their promises.
Our work on fair information, fair influence, fair votes and fair play has grown from those concerns. People need reliable information, a voice that counts and rules that stop the wealthy and powerful treating our politics as their private property. Those are the conditions in which we can make proper choices about our future.
And we will need them. Already, familiar campaign messages are returning. Claims that rejoining would cost £750 million a week. Warnings about immigration are back too. The weekly numbers have grown. The technique is familiar.
Those campaigns want us to worry about the cost of changing course. They should have to explain the price we are already paying to carry on as we are.
Brexit’s defenders need to explain what future they are offering. People leaving school today deserve rather more than an account of who won an argument when they were children.
It is encouraging, then, that today’s agreement also includes a commitment to work together on democratic resilience - protecting elections, democratic institutions and the information on which public debate depends. Alongside it is closer cooperation against foreign manipulation and interference.
Those commitments go directly to the work we are doing at Open Britain to protect people’s ability to make decisions freely. Now they need to lead to action, and we should hold the Government to that.
We have spent a decade discovering what Brexit means in practice. We now have a chance to consider what we want the next decade and beyond to look like, and what we are prepared to change to get there. That is a conversation worth having some ambition about.
There is something worth pursuing here - a chance to turn what we have learned about Brexit into something better for the people living with it. That is a conversation worth having - and worth being part of.




I was astonished, disappointed, saddened, angered and bemused when a 4% majority was sufficient to wrench the UK from the EU. What about Northern Ireland? And Gibraltar? What about our farmers and food producers? What about our freedoms to travel around Europe and live there and work there? What could Brexit offer? None of these questions were ever adequately answered by the Leave Campaign or Farage's f**kwit supporters.
Leaving Helsinki airport today. 30 minutes in the “Other passports” queue while EU citizens waltzed through the e-gates!